[Bookmarkdd] BookmarkDD feedback

[stiffux stiffux]

Hi Thanagor,


>>    * FEATURE: Add a bulk delete with a reference folder. Each duplicate
>>       included in the refence folder can automatically removed.
>
>This one sounded great, but when I try to set the root as the reference, 
>BookmarkDD yells at me in a dialog with a
>/!\ symbol: "It is not possible to select the root folder !"  That actually 
>seems to me like a very logical place to have duplicates automatically 
>deleted. Any bookmarks in subfolders have "intelligence" added to them, by 
>placing them in a category (according to the subfolder name). For my way of 
>doing things, anything in the root folder should only be there if I forgot 
>that I already have one in a subfolder.  :)

I have denied the root folder because I thought people would like to select 
it thinking this option will automaticaly delete ALL duplicates in 
subfolders ! So to avoid confusion I block root folder selection.
But, i didn't think about bookmarks within root folder (without subfolder 
;-) I will remove the code which block root folder selection and I will add 
a message to explain that only bookmarks which are not in subfolders will be 
automatically deleted.

>>    * FEATURE: Add option to automatically delete duplicate bookmarks
>>       which are in same folder.
>
>This one sounds good, but I would point out that for them to be in the same 
>folder they must have different names, in which case I personally would 
>want to compare them and keep the most intuitive name (or edit one of their 
>names). Still, the feature may be useful to some.

Sorry, but you can have some identical bookmark with the same name within 
the same subfolder !
There is no restriction made by firefox on duplicate bookmarks.

>>    * FEATURE: Add a link in Tools Menu to extension's option.
>
>This is good for testing, but as a general rule I'll keep it hidden and use 
>the context menu in the Extensions window (since the DD options wouldn't 
>change very option).

This is good for testing but also for new user who don't already know 
BookmarkDD's options.
I suspects some people to ignore that extensions' option are available throw 
extension panel !
I put an option to hide this link to keep clean Tools Menu ;-)

>>    * FEATURE: Add Option to remove button in Bookmarks Manager.
>
>Nice, but I won't need that -- I appreciate having toolbar buttons.

I also appreciate toolbar buttons but some people doesn't like them.


>>    * FEATURE: Add Option to remove menulist in Bookmarks Manager.
>
>This Search Bar addition should be very handy! I can't imagine wanting to 
>remove it.  :)

Sure ! It is very useful. I added possibility to hide it to avoid conflict 
with other extensions which also add it (in case another extension has this 
feature).

>>    * FEATURE: Add an option to show select menu in Bookmark sideBar
>>       due to little size.
>
>That is very tiny -- and you can't tell it's there until you move the mouse 
>over it. However, it should be handy for people that use bookmarks in the 
>sidebar, and once you know it's there you can find it easily. (I'm not one 
>that uses bookmarks in the sidebar, but maybe someday...)

Maybe you will use it more often now ;-)

>>    * DESIGN: New configuration panel organization.
>>    * DESIGN: Short name for button Duplicates in Bookmarks Manager.
>>    * DESIGN: Reduce menulist in Bookmarks SideBar to increase
>>       search box.
>
>All looks good! Thanks for continuing to improve such a handy tool.  :)

Thank you for you feedback which is very complete !

It is possible that I add another option to move duplicate bookmarks in a 
"duplicate" folder whereas to automatically delete them. This will avoid 
problem to manage duplicate's name to keep in Bookmarks.

Stéphane.

_________________________________________________________________
Windows Live Messenger : venez tester la version bêta ! 
http://www.ideas.live.com/programpage.aspx?versionId=0eccd94b-eb48-497c-8e60-c6313f7ebb73